One definition of a leader is âsomeone who has influence over at least one other person.â This definition puts all of us in leadership positions, some having influence over just a few individuals, others having influence over many people, with most of us falling somewhere in between.
Mosesâ Missed Opportunity
Leaders carry an awesome and sometimes frightening responsibility. We can let it shape us for Godâs glory, or we can let it take us into a self- centered realm and create trauma and damage for ourselves and those around us. In the book of Numbers, we find Moses departing from his faithful practice of spiritual leadership and doing things by his own authority and in his own way:
And Moses and Aaron gathered the assembly together before the rock; and he said to them, âHear now, you rebels! Must we bring water for you out of this rock?â Then Moses lifted his hand and struck the rock twice with his rod; and water came out abundantly, and the congregation and their animals drank. (Num. 20:10-11, New King James Version)
Moses had just come from a personal encounter with God where he received clear instructions:
Moses and Aaron went from the assembly to the entrance to the Tent of Meeting and fell facedown, and the glory of the LORD appeared to them. The LORD said to Moses, âTake the staff, and you and your brother Aaron gather the assembly together. Speak to that rock before their eyes and it will pour out its water.â (Num. 20:6-8, New International Version)
What went wrong? Was Moses afraid of another 40 years in the wilderness? Did he lose his temperâagain? Was he tired? Was he emotionally spent after the loss of his sister? Whatever the reason, Moses Don Livesay is the President of the Lake Union Conference of Seventh-day Adventists in Berrien Springs, Michigan. disobeyed God; he struck the rock instead of speaking to it. Hereâs what God said: âAnd the LORD said to Moses and Aaron, âBecause you did not believe in me, to uphold me as holy in the eyes of the people of Israel, therefore you shall not bring this assembly into the land that I have given themââ (Num. 20:12, English Standard Version). The New Living Translation renders the text: âBecause you did not trust in me enough to demonstrate my holiness to the people of Israel.â This reveals one of Godâs prime directives for His leaders: We are always to sanctify God before the people and demonstrate His holiness.
So what was the sin? Moses placed the focus on himself instead of on God: âMust we (Moses and Aaronâhuman leaders) bring water for you out of this rock?â Mosesâ attitude glorified himself instead of God and ultimately denied that God is the one who provides for the people. Furthermore, when spiritual leaders fail, the values, spiritual principles, all the powerful biblical teaching they have brought to Godâs peopleâall those things are then brought into question and often are used as an excuse for people not to follow God. God identified Mosesâ problem as a lack of faith and trust: âBecause you did not believe in me.â Moses wasted a crisis opportunityâhe lost the chance to bring a spiritual victory, a growth opportunity, for Godâs people even in their rebellion.
In a world that denies the existence of God, tries to put Him in a box, and attempts to minimize who He is and what He can do, it is our opportunity to take every chance given to maximize God in the eyes of His people and of the world. It is our prime directive to sanctify God before the people.
It is the prime goal of the evil one to keep us focused on self before the people instead of God. After all, this was at the core of Luciferâs sin: âI will ascend above the heights of the clouds; I will make myself like the Most Highâ (Isa. 14:14, New American Standard Bible). Sin was born in the heart of a  leader.
Who Does Leadership Glorify?
The battle of self is a core spiritual issue that every person must fight. We must ask ourselves the question: Who is being glorified through my leadershipâGod or me? The moment we cross that line, when self becomes our focus, we have been seduced, either by our leadership role itself or by subtle temptations within that role. The seduction of leadership is frighteningly akin to sexual immorality. The focus is on the reward that comes when self is gratified. That was Mosesâ failure. Striking the rock was all about his troubles, the threats coming from the people against him, which jeopardized his own personal gratification. Our moment of gratification gives evidence that self has been elevated instead of God, and we stand guilty of misrepresenting His holiness before the people.
Leaders face many dangers. People say a lot of nice things about us. We are given upgrades in meetings, office, and travel; we get special treatment that many other people do not receive. When we walk into a room, people notice. We always have to be âon,â so it is easy to be less than genuine. The demands of our leadership role are often so heavy, and often controlled or pushed by others, that it is easy to jump to entitlement thinkingââthe church owes me!â These and other realities in our daily experience contribute to the seduction of leadership into an internal focus on self instead of on God.
What are some warning signs that you may have been seduced by your leadership role?
- If you lose your temper in a church board or eldersâ meeting and lay the opposition low
- When in a conflict situation you worry more about how you will look than about the spiritual outcomes for the people involved and for the organization
- When you feel you are entitled to receive that which is beyond policy
- When you give more focus to image than to spiritual depth
- If after a sermon that went well you agree with the compliments that it was probably one the best sermons they ever heard
- When you are not thinking and praying about how to expand the leadership beyond your circle
- When it is easy to expect things of others that you wonât do
- When you take advantage of your position to exercise power
Lest we think this a small thing, reflect on Godâs response to Mosesâ lapse of leadership focus: âAnd the LORD said to Moses and Aaron, âBecause you did not trust me enough to demonstrate my holiness to the people of Israel, you will not lead them into the land I am giving them!ââ (Num. 20:12, NLT).
Wait a moment: had not Moses been amazingly faithful to God? Had he not been intimately engaged with God in His very presence, speaking face to face as one speaks to a friend? Had he not led the children of Israel out of Egypt? And had he not endured years of rebellion, murmuring, and disobedience by the people he led? I consider Moses to be the greatest leader in all of history, second only to our Lord Jesus. So why such a severe response from God?
God calls every believer to be a leader. By our influence, we are to help people mature in their faith in God. We are to sanctify Him in their eyes with every opportunity that life brings. In fact, the crisis at the rock was a point in the history of Israel when God desired to help His people take another step in spiritual growth in preparation to cross over Jordan into the Promised Land. The lack of water was simply an opportunity to honor God before the people and bring them to a new level of spiritual growth and confidence in Him. Mosesâ failure of leadership destroyed that opportunity for the entire nation, and Godâs response shows us the seriousness of the leaderâs failure to sanctify God before the people.
What does it look like when you sanctify God in your leadership role?
- You are an intercessor in prayer for the spiritual good of others
- Your prayer is that God is glorified, and that people see the true character of God in every interaction of your life
- You are dying to self every day
- Your humility goes beyond appearances
- Those around you tend to be inspired to seek God rather than reject Him
- You mentor those around you in a way that assists them in growing in God
Mosesâ story does not end with his failure at the rock. He did not nurse his wounds and feel sorry for himself. He could have responded with anger toward God for being so hard on him because of this one failure after many faithful years of service. But Moses chose not to stay focused on himself. Instead, he returned to a God-focused, God-sanctifying leadership. In fact, the Bible recounts many successes that Moses had after this failure! He led the Israelites around the hostile territory of Edom (Num. 20:14-21). Because he obeyed Godâs instructions and faithfully relayed them to the people, the Israelites were victorious in battle against the many enemies they faced as they approached the Promised Land (Num. 21:1-3; 21:21-35; 31:1-54). Moses also successfully managed the transition of the high priesthood to Aaronâs son Eleazar after Aaron died (Num. 20:22-29). He even asked God to select a new leader who would take his own place when God revealed to him that he too would soon die. God answered his prayer and chose Joshua to be the new leader of the Israelites (Num. 27:12-23).
Besides commissioning Joshua as his replacement, Moses also took other measures to ensure that the people would continue to follow God. He gave detailed instructions on the religious ceremonies that the people were to observe (Num. 28-29). He also gave moral and ethical instructions from the Lord which were to guide the Israelites in everyday life. One of the most impassioned pleas for obedience to God is found in Deuteronomy 30, after Moses had instructed the Israelites about Godâs law.
There were still problems that Moses faced, but he never again failed to honor God before the people. When poisonous snakes began killing the Israelites, it was Moses who appealed to God on their behalf, even though the Israelitesâ had brought this judgment upon themselves because of their complaining against God and against Moses. Moses made the bronze serpent and instructed the Israelites to look upon it to be saved (Num. 21:4-9). When the men of Israel engaged in sexual immorality and idolatry with the women of Moab, Moses followed Godâs command and told the people to execute the perpetrators (Num. 25). While such a response might seem harsh to us, it shows how seri- ously God, and Moses, took the sin of idolatry. Moses had learned the lesson of sanctifying God before the people. He would allow nothing to stand in the way of Godâs holiness being displayed to the Israelites.
Moses accepted the consequences of his sin and continued to faithfully lead Godâs people even though he would never enter the Promised Land himself. But God did allow Moses to see the Promised Land before he died. From the heights of Mount Nebo, God showed him the land that the people he had led for those 40 long years would inhabit (Deut. 34:1-4). Moses died without setting foot into the Promised Land, yet God did something even more remarkable for him. The New Testament indicates that God resurrected Moses (Jude 1:9). He was one of the two heavenly visitors who talked with Jesus on the Mount of Transfiguration (Matt. 17:3). Moses was forgiven by God and taken to the real Promised Land of heaven. His story offers reassurance that failure is not the end for leaders. Leaders who fail will suffer consequences, but when they repent they are forgiven and restored. By returning to a God-sanctifying leadership, they can still be successful leaders.
A Personal Approach to Accountability
Mosesâ experience underscores the sacred stewardship that leaders hold and the serious consequences of failing to sanctify God in our leadership. How can leaders avoid the seductive but dangerous lure of self-glorifying rather than God-sanctifying leadership? Hereâs a simple approach that has been helpful to me and has become a personal accountability statement. It is probably too simple to be anything close to profound, but you may find it useful. In every situation choose to:
Do the right thing,
In the right way,
At the right time,
And for the right reason.
Letâs break it down one section at a time.
Do the Right Thing
Of the four parts of this accountability statement, doing the right thing can, at times, be the easiest to figure outâbut not always the easiest to carry out. Several foundational qualities are characteristic of those who do the right thing even when it may be difficult. They include good judgment, sound character, and moral integrity. In addition, being open and receptive to Godâs leading through the Holy Spirit is essential.
The most powerful values that steer us to knowing what is rightâa love for Godâs law, the Golden Rule, and a godly characterâare found in Scripture. The right thing becomes clear when principles of Godâs law are employed in the context of the life of Jesus and in an atmosphere of love. Doing the right thing will always be the most right when we move away from personal subjective thinking, focus on Godâs perspective, and act in harmony with His redemptive nature.
Moses failed to do the right thing when he struck the rock instead of speaking to it as God has instructed. It might have seemed acceptable to Moses to strike the rock; after all, in a previous situation God had instructed Moses to strike the rock to bring forth water for the people (see Exod. 17:6). But precedent is not always a reliable indication of the right thing to do. The right thing in one situation is not always the right thing in another situation, no matter how similar they may appear to be. Doing what God says instead of following our own judgment is the best policy for doing the right thing in every situation we face.
Some challenges that make it difficult to do the right thing include our relentless adversary, that old serpent, and those who are guided by self. Sometimes doing the right thing is standing before a group and making a profound statement like Joshua: âAs for me and my house, we will serve the LORDâ (see Josh. 24:15). Other times it can simply be a supportive statement for a leader who is standing for right while being assailed by a small but vocal group with inappropriate agendas. A few timely statements by quiet but solid people have turned many negative meetings to the positive outcomes God intended for the mission of the church. So, standing for and doing right is a cornerstone to a spiritually sound community. But it is not the only thing on which we are to focus.
In the Right Way
The core of doing something in the right way rests in our attitude. Some operative words are âloving,â âunselfish,â ârespectful,â and âcaring.â In harmony with Godâs nature, the focus is on the best spiritual outcome for as many of those involved as possible. Mosesâ attitude when he struck the rock revealed his loss of focus. He lost sight of the spiritual outcome and failed to sanctify God before the people. His handling of the situation was not loving, unselfish, respectful, or caring. He was probably exasperated by the grumbling of the Israelites. In many ways they deserved to be rebuked! If we were in his place we might have reacted similarly. But Mosesâ reaction did not reflect the character of God.
When Christ was confronted with the woman found in sin (see John 8:2-11), He did not condemn her but approached her in a loving way that made a difference in her life. From that day on, she was a follower. He knew she had sinned, and she was painfully aware of her sin; but Christ treated her with an accountable and redemptive approach. Christ applied grace, but also moved her life upward with graceful accountability. In saving her, He also made an appeal to those who opposed Him and gave them an opportunity to sweep away the sin in their own hearts.
In confronting them, Christ was mindful of two things: He was protecting the life and heart of the woman while at the same time being sensitive to her accusers by not making a public spectacle of them.
The outcome of a good spiritual process is more likely to be redemptive when the approach follows Jesusâ example. Gentleness does not eliminate accountability. When confrontation is the right thing, the best confronter is one who has a relationship with that person. Love cares enough to help someone move away from behaviors that are destructive to self and/or others. People who are controllers can be very difficult to approach. Because of their own insecurities, they often use the following behaviors:
- Manipulation using hostility, intimidation, the martyr complex,
- Not respecting othersâ feelings, boundaries, and opinions
- Rejecting good counsel
- Inconsistently applying standards to others versus themselves
- Overreacting at an inappropriate level in relation to the actual issue in question
- Misusing inspired authority as a power tool
- Rarely accepting responsibility by deflecting away from the real issues by transferring the guilt to another
- Denying or minimizing events, twisting facts
- Claiming incomplete processes to avoid consequences
If you find yourself doing some of these things, you might be a controller. If you use this list against someone else, you might be a controller. The value of this list is to keep you objectively engaged and thus avoid letting a confrontation turn away from the real issues at hand.
A central issue around controlling behaviors is the misuse of power. Hereâs a wonderful statement written by Eugene Peterson (2003) in his introduction to 2 Corinthians in The Message: âBecause leadership is necessarily an exercise of authority, it easily shifts into an exercise of power. But the minute it does that, it begins to inflict damage on both the leader and the ledâ (p. 2090).
Itâs worth reading a second time. In a review of the vast majority of conflicts Iâve worked through as an administrator, power is nearly always at the core of each conflict. Godly leadership is not about self; itâs about God, His plan, and His power for the salvation of all who will accept. People who focus on exercising power over others often attempt to control with the behaviors listed above. If you find yourself doing any of those behaviors, you are probably attempting to use power to control others. Petersonâs statement says it well, but there is often a thin line between appropriate authority and using power. When leaders carefully exercise godly authority, the outcome can be wonderfully appropriate. When the use of power enters into the equation, the leader and those led are damagedâas well as Godâs cause.
Eugene Kennedy and Sara Charles address this in their book, Authority:
Authority is from the Latin word augÄre, which means to create, to enlarge, to enable growth. Yet because authority is so often confused with authoritarianism, or the urge to control by power, we exclude it from our vocabularies and from our lives. Authority is actually the nurturing ingredient in our roles as parents, employees, spouses, teachers, lovers, and friends. Healthy authority is about neither power nor control.
In its truest sense, authority means to author something from within oneselfâa good marriage, a family, a book, a job, an idea; or to engage in creative works of other typesâto love another, to teach students, to start a business, to help the sick, to secure justice for those to whom it has been denied. These works depend on the natural exercise of healthy and constructive authority.
Authority does not control, it authors. (Kennedy & Charles, 1997, book jacket)
I believe the huge misunderstanding of our God is that He is just some authoritarian making unilateral decisions about people with no care, no love, and certainly no compassion. It is of eternal consequence for us to understand that God, the most powerful being in the universe, is not an arbitrary judge, not a dictator, not authoritarianâHe is, in fact, an Author of our lives, our future, and our salvation. His plan,
His sacrifice, all that He is, is about carefully, lovingly fashioning us for fulfillment now and a joyous eternity. In fact, Paul understood this concept when he wrote in Hebrews 12:2: âLooking unto Jesus the author and finisher of our faith; who for the joy that was set before him endured the cross, despising the shame, and is set down at the right hand of the throne of Godâ (King James Version, emphasis supplied).
At the Right Time
Timing can be the most difficult of the four principles to apply. When is the right time to address a conflict or problem? It is common for a leader to know what should be done and how to do it long before knowing when the time is right. Timing especially needs to be subject to the Holy Spiritâs leading. Remember, the most important goal is reaching the best spiritual outcome. When a person is engaged in hurting someone emotionally, physically, or spiritually, our response should usually be very quick. But there are many cases when acting too soon will increase damage and responding too late will allow more damage than necessary. With focused and caring prayer, God will provide signals that indicate that the time for action has arrived. Often, issues of courage or fear, stubbornness and self, will inhibit our understanding Godâs timing. Paulâs description of dying to self is important so we can know Godâs timing. Timing is often a huge factor in good outcomes.
For the Right Reason
Our personal motives in leadership are the primary engines of good outcomes. Remember, control is not our goal; good spiritual function, personal growth, and quality outcomes are the goal. If our focus turns to self, motives are compromised. If we are operating in godly love and altruistic concern for others, we are probably doing things for the right reason. The right or wrong reason for doing something often dramatically shapes the first three parts of the accountability list. Itâs a good question to ask ourselves as we look in the mirror: Why am I doing this?
Those who feel that doing the right thing is the only necessity in dealing with people often cause much damage. Each of the four parts of accountability is core to sanctifying God before the people.
Those in administrative leadership face unique challenges in the battle of self that others do not. Leaders who have the greatest influence have the greatest responsibility. One of the most painful realities of leadership is that our mistakes, whether moral failures or simple misjudgments, can be used by the evil one to conjure up excuses in the hearts of followers to avoid doing the right thing. But hereâs the wonderful side of the stewardship of leadership: the greater a leaderâs influence, the more opportunity God has to encourage His saints and build up their faith in Him. God still needs leaders to lead His people to the Promised Land, leaders who will take every opportunity to sanctify Him before the people.
References
- Kennedy, E., & Charles, S. C. (1997). Authority: How Americans can regain the satisfaction they miss at home, at work, and in public life. New York, NY: The Free Press.
- Peterson, E. H. (2003). The message remix: The Bible in contemporary language. Colorado Springs, CO: NavPress.
Don Livesay is the President of the Lake Union Conference of Seventh-day Adventists in Berrien Springs, Michigan.